It hurts everyone

Recently I was speaking with someone who was using the anemic moral argument, “…as long as it doesn’t hurt anyone…” That set my mind thinking about the Christian understanding of the social nature of sin, which posits a certain “butterfly effect” in every good or evil deed. Even the most secret inner evil thought, as Fr. Zosima says in The Brothers Karamozov, poisons the whole universe, while the most secret act of charity brings light into the farthest reaches of darkness.

Then I came across this quote from 19th century French convert Léon Bloy, which I discovered in a terrific article, that makes this same point with the literary artistry Bloy is known for:

Every man who begets a free act projects his personality into the infinite. If he gives a poor man a penny grudgingly, that penny pierces the poor man’s hand, falls, pierces the earth, bores holes in suns, crosses the firmament and compromises the universe. If he begets an impure act, he perhaps darkens thousands of hearts whom he does not know, who are mysteriously linked to him, and who need this man to be pure as a traveler dying of thirst needs the Gospel’s draught of water. A charitable act, an impulse of real pity sings for him the divine praises, from the time of Adam to the end of the ages; it cures the sick, consoles those in despair, calms storms, ransoms prisoners, converts the infidel and protects mankind.

5 comments on “It hurts everyone

  1. […] Recently I was speaking with someone who was using the anemic moral argument, “…as long as it doesn’t hurt anyone…” That set my mind thinking about the Christian understanding of the social nature of sin, which posits a certain “butterfly effect” in every good or evil deed. Even the most …read more […]

  2. beads2rosaries says:

    In my own experience, when I try to convince myself that no one “else” got hurt, I am trying to avoid the realization that the person I have hurt most is “self”. I always think about tossing confetti, thrown high into the air and thinking the breeze will carry it far from me. Yet, I know from experience that the wind creates the chaos which lands most of the shreds of paper squarely upon my shoulders once again.

  3. DZSJ-AMDG says:

    I agree with the words of wisdom from beads2rosaries. Through the most private of sins one still harms oneself and this harming of oneself isolates the person from the fullness of life. It becomes a hurdle in one’s self-image, one’s relationship with others and with God. I am thinking of Pope Francis’ most recent tweet that in a sense speaks to the opposite: “@Pontifex: Let us allow Jesus into our lives and leave behind our selfishness, indifference and closed attitude to others.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s